Triple-isotope analysis in tree-ring cellulose suggests only moderate effects of tree species mixture on the climate sensitivity of silver fir and Douglas-fir.

Disentangling the factors influencing the climate sensitivity of trees is crucial to understanding the susceptibility of forests to climate change. Reducing tree-to-tree competition and mixing tree species are two strategies often promoted to reduce the drought sensitivity of trees, but it is unclear how effective these measures are in different ecosystems. Here, we studied the growth and physiological responses to climate and severe droughts of silver fir and Douglas-fir growing in pure and mixed conditions at three sites in Switzerland. We used tree-ring width (TRW) data and carbon (δ13C), oxygen (δ18O) and hydrogen (δ2H) stable isotope ratios from tree-ring cellulose to gain novel information on water relations and the physiology of trees in response to drought and how tree species mixture and competition modulate these responses. We found significant differences in isotope ratios between trees growing in pure and mixed conditions for the two species, although these differences varied between sites, e.g. trees growing in mixed conditions had higher δ13C values and TRW than trees growing in pure conditions for two of the sites. For both species, differences between trees in pure and mixed conditions regarding their sensitivity to temperature, precipitation, climatic water balance and vapor pressure deficit (VPD) were minor. Further, trees growing in pure and mixed conditions showed similar responses of TRW and isotope ratios to the past severe droughts of 2003, 2015 and 2018. Competition had only a significantly negative effect on δ13C of silver fir, which may suggest a decrease in photosynthesis due to higher competition for light and nutrients. Our study highlights that tree species mixture may have only moderate effects on the radial growth and physiological responses of silver fir and Douglas-fir to climatic conditions and that site condition effects may dominate over mixture effects.